Is the United States a Declining Superpower?

Earl H. Fry, Professor of Political Science, Brigham Young University

Video, MP3, and PDF Flyer available here. Notes follow:  

  • “Gathering clouds and raging storms”
  • We are declining, in relative terms
  • Relatively low ranking in longevity and infant mortality
  • 20th Century was undeniably the “American Century”
    • WWII
      • GDP, military force, nuclear weapons
    • Cold War
      • USSR was a military superpower, but not an economic one
    • Post-Cold War
      • United States as the sole superpower (“hyperpower”)
  • 2008
    • Approximately 25% world GDP
    • Population growth – projected to reach 420 million by 2050
    • Population will decline throughout many other parts of the world
  • A superpower in relative decline
    • By 2040, superpowers will no longer be relevant
    • 3 fundamental explanations
      • The demands of globalization
      • Rise of competing nations and groups of nations
      • Failure of the United States to adequately confront world problems
  • Globalization
    • Growing interconnectedness / interdependency
    • Many problems will be beyond the capability of individual nations to solve unilaterally
      • Environmental issues – increased use of fossil fuels in developing economies
    • Premium placed on multilateral cooperation
    • Technological accelerators
    • Creative destruction
      • 30 million jobs created, 29 million jobs lost
      • Auto industry vs. IT industry
    • Interconnectedness
      • Resources, Environment, Energy, Terrorism, Economics, Weapons Proliferation, Conflict, Sports and Entertainment, Internet, Immigration, Religion and Ideology, Culture, Crime, Disease
  • Rise of Global Competitors
    • China, India, European Union, ASEAN, Japan, Russia, Brazil, Indonesia
  • Problems at Home
    • Record levels of federal government debt
    • World’s largest external debtor country
      • More than $5 trillion deficit in goods between 2000 and 2008
    • Household debt has doubled over the past seven years, borrowed on equity
    • Entitlement explosion
      • Almost 1/4 of Americans will soon retire (fewer workers than retirees)
    • Out-of-control health-care spending
      • We spend more, but have a lower amount of coverage than other Western nations
      • We spend twice as much as other Western nations
    • Education deficit
      • Focus on K-12
    • Infrastructure deficiencies
      • Poor broadband penetration
    • Problems within the Beltway
      • Special interests vs. General interests
      • Campaign finance difficulties
      • Inability to tackle major problems in a non-partisan manner
    • Overextended international commitments
      • Wars in Iraq and Afghanistan
      • Forward-deterrence strategy
      • Nation-building problems
  • Plight of the Average American
    • Jobs
      • Unemployment and underemployment
      • Negative wealth effect
    • Home Equity
      • Many home owners “under water”
    • Retirement Accounts
      • S&P fell 37% in 2008
  • The Future
    • Current problems are greater than most people realize; current recession the worst ever experienced by most Americans
    • American economy will continue to grow, but diminish in importance
    • Standard of living will be appreciably better
    • Prepare for a world where technological change and information creation will be more rapid than any other time in human history
    • Learn to cope with creative destruction
    • Prepare to change jobs several times during your working careers
    • Keep learning
    • Let the Gospel be an anchor and source of stability in a rapidly changing national and international environment
    • Prepare for very exciting times
    • Although military prowess will be important, our future importance will be based on the best features of democracy, capitalism, integrity, creativity, and Christian principles
    • George Bernard Shaw: “Some look at things that are, and ask why. I dream of things that never were and ask why not?”
    • Standing for Something by Gordon B. Hinckley
    • Be a part of an active, informed, and engaged citizenry
    • Become leaders

Comments are closed.